Here’s the tension at the heart of whether you should replace your gutters when you replace your roof: keeping a set of solid gutters saves you money today. But swapping them while the crew is already here saves you the hassle and cost of doing it all over again later.
The right call really does come down to the shape your current gutters are in.

The Short Answer
If your gutters are in good shape (they aren’t leaking, sagging, rusting, or pulling away from the house), there’s no rule that says they have to go just because the roof is coming off.
A careful crew can work around them and leave them right where they are.
If they’re already weathered, though, replacing them alongside the roof is usually the better value.
Here’s a quick way to see which side you’re on.
| Keep your gutters if… | Replace your gutters if… |
| They’re solid and firmly attached | They sag, leak, or pull away from the fascia |
| There’s no rust or cracked seams | You see rust, splits, or open joints |
| Water drains cleanly in a rain | Water sheets over the edges when it rains |
| They still look right with the house | They’re mismatched or plain worn out |
Do Gutters Always Come Off During a Roof Replacement?
Not usually. Unless you’re replacing them, your gutters stay put during a roof job. The crew protects them, keeps ladders off the gutter face, and clears out any debris that falls in before they leave.
When we do take them off, it’s for a reason.
Sometimes the fascia board behind the gutter needs repair, or the drip edge along the roof’s edge needs to go on, which is easier with the gutters out of the way. That’s exactly what a proper roof inspection reveals, so nothing about your gutters catches you off guard mid-project.
Why So Many Homeowners Do Both at Once

There are a few good reasons people decide to knock out the gutters while the roof is being replaced. They mostly come down to convenience and doing the job right.
- One crew, one warranty, one call. When the same company handles the roof and the gutters, you make one payment, and you have one number to call if anything ever needs attention. Nobody points fingers between a roofing company and a separate gutter company.
- The access is already there. Your roofer is up at the roofline anyway, so adding gutters then is far less disruptive than scheduling a whole second project later.
- The edge details line up. New gutters, a fresh drip edge, and clean fascia working together are what keep water moving off your roof and away from your foundation.
- Matching looks. If you’re getting a new roof color, worn old gutters can make a fresh roof appear half-finished. New gutters let the whole thing look new from the street.
Pro Tips Before You Decide

- Ask for a straight read on your gutters. A trustworthy roofer will tell you honestly whether yours have real life left, even when the answer costs them a gutter sale.
- Bring up the fascia early. If there’s any rot or soft wood behind the gutters, it’s cheapest to handle while everything’s open, so ask about it before the crew starts.
- Think about capacity. If your old gutters overflow in a hard Georgia downpour, upgrading to a larger size while you’re at it can fix a problem you’ve lived with for years.
- Time it right. New gutters go on after the new roof, so the drip edge and shingles land in the correct order.
A Couple Things Homeowners Often Ask
Can I replace gutters later without touching the roof?
Yes. You can replace gutters on their own anytime, so if yours are fine now, there’s no need to do them today. It’s purely about whether a second project later is worth it to you.
Will new gutters really protect my new roof?
They work together. Gutters carry water away from the fascia, foundation, and siding. When they fail, that water can find its way back to the very roof edge you just paid to redo.
Not Sure Yours Need to Go? We’ll Check for You
The easiest way to settle this is to have us check your roof and your gutters in one visit and tell you honestly what each one needs.
Call us at (770) 370-7663 or message us here.
If new gutter installation makes sense alongside your roof replacement, we’ll fold it into one project and one quote.